Magazine “Research” · Reading time approx. 7 min
44 studies, 4,617 families: Systemic therapy helps children and adolescents somewhat more than other treatments. It was not demonstrably important who judged the outcome.
Why the Question Matters Right Now
Since 12 April 2024, a decision of the Federal Joint Committee (Gemeinsamer Bundesausschuss, G-BA) has been in force. The G-BA is the body that decides which treatments Germany’s statutory health insurance covers. Under it, systemic therapy is also among the recognised approaches for children and adolescents. According to this announcement, however, it can only be billed to the health insurers once their fee schedule (the EBM, the catalogue that sets what practitioners are paid under statutory health insurance) has been adjusted. For adults, the insurers have been paying since 2020.
Anyone who advises parents will soon hear the question: Does it actually help? A new analysis by a team around Niels Braus gives an answer. It first appeared online in October 2025 and is now in the November 2026 issue of the journal “Psychotherapy Research”. The team comes from Witten/Herdecke, Kassel and Vienna.
One thing up front: we have not read the full article, only the published abstract. Where we go beyond it, we say so.
What the Team Did
A meta-analysis collects many individual studies and combines their results. Here there were 44 studies with a total of 4,617 families. In each of them, the children or adolescents had a diagnosis, and it was decided by lot who received systemic therapy and who received a different psychosocial treatment.
Most studies measured several things, for example with different questionnaires. This added up to 370 individual results, just over eight per study. The team’s calculation method takes into account that results from the same study are related to one another, and does not treat them as if they were independent findings. The team also checked how reliably the individual studies had been designed. What came out of that is not stated in the abstract.
The Result: A Small but Real Edge
Systemic therapy performed better than the comparison treatments. The edge is small; the authors say so themselves. But it is statistically well supported, which means it is very probably not down to chance. In numbers: the effect size is 0.16, and the true value very probably lies between 0.09 and 0.23.
What is interesting is where the edge shows up. Not only in the children’s symptoms (0.19), but equally in how the family gets along (0.12) and in the strain on the parents (0.12).
The three values are close to one another, and the authors call them comparable. Whether the family or the child benefits somewhat more cannot be read from this. Something else is what matters: the effect shows up in the whole family, not only in the child with whom it all began.
Who Judges Makes No Difference
The team had expected the result to depend on who assesses it and how it is measured. That was not confirmed. The edge was similar no matter who judged and which method was used.
To be precise: the data show no reliable difference. That there is none at all is not proven by this. Which groups of assessors these were in detail is not stated in the abstract.
Why “Small” Means More Here Than It Sounds
0.16 seems modest. But you have to look at what was compared: not a waiting list, but other treatments. There, too, families receive attention, structure and care. That two treatments lie closer together than a treatment and doing nothing is generally well known in psychotherapy research. That is our own interpretation, not a statement of this study.
So a small value does not mean “hardly helps”. It means: systemic therapy was somewhat more effective than what it was compared with.
Where the Findings Reach Their Limits
The authors themselves name one important limitation. Most of the results come from questionnaires in which the people involved rate their own symptoms. That makes the findings less robust. They therefore hope for a wider variety of measurement types in future. At the same time, they see their results as evidence that systemic therapy improves family life and relieves parents.
In addition there is what we cannot see without the full article: which individual studies they were, how long the treatment lasted, how old the children were, and how the assessment of study quality turned out.
What This Means for Working with Families
From here on, it is our own reflection, not a statement of the study. If therapy also changes family life and the strain on the parents, it is worth keeping exactly that in view from the start. A genogram helps with this, because it shows the whole family and not only the child with the diagnosis.
Hypothetical case example: A twelve-year-old boy comes to counselling because he has not been going to school for weeks. At first everything revolves around his behaviour. While drawing the genogram together, the counsellor asks who in the family looks after whom. The mother says that for two years she has been caring for her own mother, sleeps badly and is often absent from work. The boy says quietly that he does not want to leave her alone in the mornings. After that, it is no longer about the “problem child”, but about how the family can manage the care together.
A moment like this cannot be derived from the meta-analysis. But it fits its finding that relief for the parents is also part of the outcome. In GenoEasy you can add notes to persons and partnerships, so that such a connection stays visible on the map.
What research knows about the genogram itself, you can read in our article What Does Effectiveness Research Say About the Genogram?
How to draw a genogram together with children and adolescents is shown in the Academy lesson Genogram Work with Children and Adolescents.
Takeaways
Systemic therapy gives children and adolescents a small but reliable edge over other treatments, and for the family and the parents as well. Whether this depends on who judges the outcome could not be demonstrated. That leaves a simple question for practice: Which changes in the family do you record, and how?
Sources
- Braus, N., Flückiger, C., Wichmann, J., Frankman, C., Gräfenkämper, R., Zemp, M. & Hunger-Schoppe, C. (2026): Who determines the outcome? A three-level meta-analysis on systemic therapy in children and adolescents. Psychotherapy Research 36(8), 1427–1441. https://doi.org/10.1080/10503307.2025.2565236
- Gemeinsamer Bundesausschuss [Federal Joint Committee] (2024): news item of 12.04.2024, “Beschluss zur Systemischen Therapie für Kinder und Jugendliche in Kraft” [“Decision on systemic therapy for children and adolescents comes into force”], g-ba.de